Tyler Robinson, 22, the accused in the shooting death of Charlie Kirk, made his initial court appearance via camera before Fourth District Judge Tony Graf in Provo, Utah, on September 16, 2025. The issue of media access to courtroom proceedings in this high-profile case is currently being evaluated on a case-by-case basis. Judge Graf emphasized that any requests from prosecutors or defense attorneys to limit media coverage in future hearings must be communicated to several news organizations. This process allows journalists the opportunity to review and object to any motions for closure. However, the judge did not make a determination on the broader question of whether news cameras will be prohibited from future courtroom proceedings. Defense attorneys have indicated plans to restrict media access. Robinson faces charges of aggravated murder, a capital offense, along with six additional counts related to the killing of Kirk on September 10. Prosecutors have stated their intention to pursue the death penalty if Robinson is convicted. The defendant is accused of firing a single shot that fatally struck Kirk during a public speaking event at Utah Valley University in Orem. Robinson’s defense has raised concerns about the extensive media coverage of the case and its potential impact on jury selection, though it may be years before the case goes to trial. Robinson's defense attorney, Kathryn Nester, opted not to provide comments following the court session. Judge Graf also declined requests from two media coalitions seeking official party status, asserting that they do not need such designation to advocate for public access to court proceedings. Jeff Hunt, an attorney specializing in First Amendment rights, noted the judge's commitment to maintaining public access and transparency while also safeguarding the rights of the defendant. The judge has mandated the release of transcripts and audio recordings from a previously closed hearing concerning Robinson’s attire and restraints in court, with expected availability later this week. Judge Graf acknowledged the national and international attention surrounding the case, which presents certain threats to involved parties. He has previously ruled that Robinson must wear restraints in court but can don civilian clothing.